I love my job but if the Government ever forces me to scare my students in the name of “science” I will plainly refuse. I would sooner lose my job than transfer the negatively geared, sensationalistic, propaganda, intended at frightening children into believing that the world is going to go to bits because of man-made global warming.
I am more than happy to help motivate my students to care for their environment and reduce their own carbon footprints – this is a positive message. However, the Government, United Nations and various scientific agencies have no interest in positive messages. Their game is to fill our young impressionable children with fear and dread. These people believe that a nightmare in the name of science makes the experience worthwhile.
Just watch this advertisement below. This is no underground commercial. This was played at the Copenhagen Climate Summit. It is absolutely appalling! It has as much scientific value as a mound of cow turd! How dare they use children like that. What manipulative cowards they are! Who needs to communicate truths when you can terrorise children?
Anthony Sharwood is right in his assessment of this advertisement and the message we our sending our impressionable young:
One of the worst things I’ve seen in ages was the Copenhagen Climate Summit opening film, where a small child has terrible, apocalyptic nightmares after learning about human-induced climate change.
He is also correct in offering a much more palatable alternative in teaching the challenges of conserving our environment.
My six year old daughter has been learning about Earth Hour at school. Want to know how to really inspire her and others like her to save the world? Get them to love it, not fear it. Allow them to develop their own sense of environmental responsibility, rather than indoctrinating them to feel part of a “problem”.
I’m not a perfect parent. If anyone has an IKEA-style parenthood manual complete with helpful Swedish pictograms, please loan it to me. But one piece of parenting I think I’ve gotten right is instilling a deep love of nature in both my kids.
Together, we’ve bushwalked, skied and swum in some of Australia’s most beautiful locations. We’ve thrown summer snowballs on a New Zealand volcano and caught (and then released) tadpoles in a clear, Blue Mountains stream.
At home, I teach my kids about clouds and the wind direction, and always Google the birds that alight on our backyard trees, so that we can observe their habits armed with a few facts. How many city kids do you know that tell the difference between a white cockatoo and a Corella?
One day, I hope my daughter becomes an environmental scientist or activist who helps save the world. More likely, she’ll live a regular life with a regular job, and that’ll be fine too. Either way, I’m sure she’ll choose to pursue a lifestyle of modest consumption and environmental light-stepping.
If ever called on to teach this subject in such a negative way I will flatly refuse. If they force an educational pack on me I will immediately throw it in the bin (recycle bin, of course).
One wonders why those investing time into spreading the message about our carbon footprint consistently put their foot in it.
Tags: Alarmism, Anthony Sharwood, Climate Change, Copenhagen Climate Summit, Earth Hour, Education, Electricity, Environment, Fear, Film, Global Warming, Google, life, Parenting

March 6, 2012 at 12:54 am |
Michael, while I see your point about purposefully producing scare-tactic propaganda for elementary viewing, I’d argue that what we just experienced in the Midwest of my country (USA) felt and looked somewhat like this piece. Know that those kids living in our “tornado alley” know how much scarier their experiences are compared to the rest of the country.
As in all teaching, the tools must be age appropriate, and be part of a larger curriculum. This piece would be an unnecessary negative drain without a larger context. I would argue, this would make a great piece in a high school for exploring in science, math (probability), and language arts with social studies (propaganda). While I agree with the underlying message, it is a piece of propaganda nonetheless. There is a place for it and a context and real educators will understand that and use it to it’s strength.
March 6, 2012 at 1:02 am |
Thanks Dorna Luna. I appreciate alternate points of view.
March 9, 2012 at 10:01 pm |
[…] filed under Uncategorized, Climate Change. You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS 2.0 feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site. Share No related posts […]
May 1, 2012 at 2:26 pm |
gerat post…
[…]Our Children and the Disgusting Climate of Fear « Topical Teaching[…]…
May 31, 2012 at 5:55 pm |
There is definately a great deal to find out about this topic.
I love all the points you have made.
March 2, 2013 at 7:59 am |
Usually I don’t read article on blogs, but I wish to say that this write-up very pressured me to take a look at and do so! Your writing style has been amazed me. Thanks, very great article.